SOAP – Strengths and Weaknesses
-
Pros:
-
SOAP isn’t inherently bad as a communication mechanism.
-
XML, while verbose, provides validation benefits.
-
Strong contract via WSDL is SOAP’s biggest strength – great for validation and documentation.
-
-
Cons:
-
SOAP Envelope is inefficient and adds overhead.
-
Poor response granularity: limited to 200 OK or 500 Fault.
-
Implementation challenges more than protocol flaws.
-
The Promise of SOA
-
Offered strong contracts and easy inter-service communication.
-
Helped solve deployment issues in monolithic architectures.
-
Enabled Business Process Orchestration (BPO) for wiring services together.
The Reality and Decline
-
BPO became complex, tightly coupled, and code-heavy.
-
Abstracted logic led to hidden dependencies and fragile systems.
-
Developer visibility into service wiring was poor.
-
Systems became bloated with “spaghetti code” and painful to deploy.
-
Ultimately, managing the SOA ecosystem became more cumbersome than handling a monolith.
Conclusion
- While SOA had great theoretical value, its practical implementations introduced complexities that led to its decline in favor of simpler, more agile solutions.